Should he stay or should he go

0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 Google+ 0 Reddit 0 Pin It Share 0 Buffer 0 Buffer 0 Flares ×

When Mariano Rivera went down with a season ending knee injury in early May, many thought the Yankees would pay dearly for not having the greatest relief pitcher of all-time closing out games down the stretch-run to October. Well, they were wrong.

The closer has been one of the bright spots of this Yankees team in 2012, amidst a season of injuries and inconsistent play. Rafael Soriano has been a rock in the ninth inning, putting up one of his best years as a closer.

When the Yankees signed Soriano, GM Brian Cashman was hesitant in giving a setup man a lot of money; the move was more of an upper-management decision. Coming off a career year with Tampa Bay in 2010, New York signed Soriano in January of 2011 for three years at $35 million to Rivera’s setup man. Eventually, David Robertson took over as the setup guy, relegating Soriano to the seventh inning. Initially, the signing looked to be a burden as Soriano had a pedestrian year last year, 2-3 with a 4.12 ERA. But when Rivera went down, Robertson failed as the closer, giving Soriano a shot he’s fully taken advantage of. He has 40 saves, 2.o7 ERA, and 63 strikeouts in 61 innings.

There was a catch with that contact however. Soriano can opt-out after this season, which would make him a free agent. With Mariano expected to be healthy for next season, would Soriano opt-out and look for a closer’s job somewhere else and hope for more money? I think he most definitely will. His success as a seventh inning or setup guy doesn’t compare to what he does in the ninth. He’s more comfortable and more dominant when he closes games. Clearly, he came to the Yankees because of the money. Now, I think he’ll leave because of money. Soriano will have a lot of leverage in negotiations regardless – when he picked up the save yesterday, he became just the fourth Yankee since 1969 to reach the 40th save plateau, joining Rivera, Dave Righetti and John Wetteland – not bad company at all.

2013 will probably be Rivera’s last season. Should the Yankees resign Soriano to another mult-year contract? The guy has proven he can handle the job and close in the AL East for the Rays and now the Yankees. He’ll be 33 years old in December and there’s no guarantee he’ll be the ageless wonder Rivera has been. If he leaves, who will replace him? The Yankees have a lot of questions to ask as this season comes to a close. But for now, New York and their fans hope the season ends with Soriano closing the last game in October.

Rich Kaufman

Ever since my parents bought me a Paul O'Neill shirt at my first Yankees game back in 1994 I've been a diehard fan. I graduated from Springfield College in Springfield, Mass., in 2011 with a degree in Communications/Sports Journalism, so writing about the Yankees has always been a passion of mine.

Latest posts by Rich Kaufman (see all)

0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 Google+ 0 Reddit 0 Pin It Share 0 Buffer 0 Buffer 0 Flares ×
  • http://twitter.com/Nick_BD Nick_BD

    This is a tough one. Mo will be back as closer so Soriano will have to set up again and we saw how that worked out. I’d like him to stay but 12m is a lot of a set up guy. But I also wouldn’t mind if he left with Joba (I know hasn’t pitched well but first month of the DL he will get better), Aardsma (a decent closer for Seattle) and Mo will all be back. Add Robertson who hasn’t pitched well since his injury either but after a good rest I think he will be ok. I’m sure Cashman will bring someone in aswell at a decent price I think we will be fine.

  • jden821

    I am also a die hard Yankee fan and I truly believe that Soriano should stay, because Mariano’s return will be for 1 more year (if there are no setbacks in his rehab). Therefore, there is still a chance he can be the closer again next year and if not after that the job is his to lose. After all, who else do the Yankees have? Robertson was given the opportunity and didn’t take advantage of it. Noone else in sight right now.

0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 Google+ 0 Reddit 0 Pin It Share 0 Buffer 0 Buffer 0 Flares ×