There wasn’t much argument for it on Opening Day. There wasn’t much argument for it even at the trade deadline. But J.A. Happ gives the Yankees the best chance at winning the Wild Card Game. He’s easily the most consistent pitcher the Yanks have right now, and the playoffs are all about right now.
|Last 7 days||0||0||1.80||1||5.0||5||1||1||1||2||0||7||0||0||21||1.400||12.6||3.50|
|Last 14 days||0||0||0.82||2||11.0||9||2||1||1||5||0||13||0||0||46||1.273||10.6||2.60|
|Last 28 days||1||0||2.30||5||27.1||27||8||7||5||6||0||24||1||2||113||1.207||7.9||4.00|
Let’s look at Happ’s recent numbers. The southpaw hasn’t lost a game in a month. He’s pitched to the fine tune of a 2.30 ERA and 1.21 WHIP. He’s consistent. Does he have as high a ceiling as Luis Severino or Masahiro Tanaka? Definitely not. But what the Yankees need in the Wild Card is a pitcher with a high floor, not necessarily a high ceiling. With their bullpen, the Yankees just need a starter to keep them in the game and get through five, maybe six innings. That screams Happ. He doesn’t walk a ton of guys, he doesn’t give up too many home runs, and he strikes batters out at a respectable clip.
Plus, Happ has proven his worth against the Oakland Athletics. He’s made one start against them this year, tossing 6 innings of 2 hit, 1 run ball. Lifetime, he holds a solid 3.47 ERA over 59.2 innings. And in Yankee Stadium, where in all probability this game will be, Happ’s numbers are strong. Across 39.2 innings this season, his ERA is just 2.72. In his career, it’s only about a half run lower at a still respectable 3.39.
|vs RH Starter||1041||102||3953||3530||520||902||202||15||146||498||26||14||341||864||.256||.325||.445||.771||1572||80||42||5||35||11||40||.296||101||110|
|vs LH Starter||611||56||2150||1919||270||478||114||5||73||259||9||5||190||476||.249||.326||.428||.754||821||53||33||1||7||6||12||.294||98||108|
In addition, as shown above the A’s are actually slightly worse offensively against left-handed starters than righties. Their batting average, slugging percentage and OPS are all slightly lower against lefties. Does that mean CC Sabathia should start? No. But it does add extra weight to a Happ consideration.
Happ also has solid postseason numbers. Do the Yankees want another Severino blow up like last year? Do you want a home run prone Tanaka? You can’t take those risks in a do-or-die game. In his two postseason starts in 2016, Happ went 5 innings/1 run and 5 innings/2 runs. That’s fine. That’s more than fine with this offense hitting the way it has been since Judge returned.
Happ isn’t the sexiest name to start the wild card, but he doesn’t need to be. Save the higher ceiling pitchers for when it’s not do-or-die in the ALDS, for when there’s some wriggle room to take chances. During Wednesday’s broadcast both David Cone and Michael Kay argued how Happ was the Yankees best pitcher over the last month. So why would we risk pitching Tanaka or Severino? Because they’re bigger names? Higher ceiling pitchers? If the Yankees want the best chance at getting through to the ALDS, Happ is the answer.