2016 Yankees

Record84-78(.519)
PostseasonDid Not Qualify
Finish4th in AL East · 9.0 GB
ManagerJoe Girardi
Runs / Allowed680/702
Run Diff-22

The 2016 Yankees went 84-78 and missed the playoffs, and on paper that sounds like a forgettable season. It was anything but. This was the year Brian Cashman blew it up -- traded Andrew Miller, Aroldis Chapman, and Carlos Beltran at the deadline -- and got back the prospects who'd change the franchise forever. This was the year a 23-year-old catcher named Gary Sanchez hit 20 homers in 53 games and made every Yankee fan believe -- really believe -- that the future was going to be spectacular. And this was the year Alex Rodriguez and Mark Teixeira played their final games in pinstripes, four home runs short of 700 and out of runway. The Baby Bombers weren't born in 2017. They were born right here.

The Sell-Off

For the first time since 1989, the Yankees were sellers at the trade deadline. Let that sink in. The Yankees. Selling. It felt wrong, like watching your dad admit he couldn't fix the sink. But Cashman saw the bigger picture, and the deals he made in late July and early August will go down as some of the shrewdest in franchise history.

On July 25, the team sat at 51-48, 7.5 games out of first with just a 5.1% chance of making the playoffs. That day, Cashman traded Aroldis Chapman to the Chicago Cubs for a prospect package headlined by shortstop Gleyber Torres -- one of the Cubs' top prospects and a future All-Star. Also included: outfielders Rashad Crawford and Billy McKinney, plus pitcher Adam Warren.

On July 31, the fire sale continued. Andrew Miller -- the best reliever in baseball at that moment -- went to the Cleveland Indians for outfielder Clint Frazier and left-hander Justus Sheffield. On August 1, 39-year-old Carlos Beltran was shipped to the Texas Rangers for pitchers Dillon Tate, Erik Swanson, and Nick Green.

Three trades. Three veteran stars moved. A pile of prospects acquired. The Yankees had officially waved the white flag on 2016 -- and planted the flag for 2017 and beyond.

The August Nobody Expected

Here's the thing that baffled everyone: after gutting the roster, the Yankees got better. The young players who filled the vacancies played with energy and hunger. The August surge was real -- the team played winning baseball after the deadline, not despite the trades but maybe because of them. With less pressure and more opportunity, the kids performed.

The clubhouse mood shifted from "save our season" to "show what you've got." And what they had, it turned out, was Gary Sanchez.

The Gary Sanchez Show

Nobody saw Sanchez coming -- at least not this fast. The 23-year-old catcher was called up in August and immediately started mashing. Twenty home runs in 53 games. Twenty. That's a pace of roughly 60 homers over a full season, which is obviously unsustainable, but the raw power was real. He hit balls into the upper deck. He hit balls out of the park on pitches that had no business being hit. (He was like a video game character someone had forgotten to program with realistic limitations.)

Sanchez wasn't just a power hitter -- he was the embodiment of the organizational pivot. While the veterans were being traded away, here was a homegrown prospect proving that the farm system could produce legitimate impact talent. For a franchise that had spent decades buying stars rather than developing them, Sanchez's emergence felt like validation.

The End for A-Rod and Teixeira

Alex Rodriguez announced on August 7 that he'd play his final game on August 12. He was four home runs short of 700 and wasn't going to get there. The organization had moved on -- the fire sale made that clear -- and A-Rod's declining production (.200 average at the time) gave them no reason to keep running him out there.

His final game was emotional and awkward in equal measure. The fans gave him a standing ovation. His teammates hugged him. The franchise that had paid him over $350 million across 12 seasons said goodbye with a combination of relief and genuine affection. (The A-Rod experience was always complicated. Even the farewell was complicated.)

Mark Teixeira also finished his career in 2016, retiring after eight seasons at first base. He'd been a steady, professional presence -- 206 home runs in pinstripes, a Gold Glove defender -- who never quite reached the heights the contract ($180 million over eight years) had promised. His exit was quieter than A-Rod's but no less significant. These were the last links to the 2009 championship team, and watching them leave felt like closing a door that had been creaking for years.

Record84-78 (4th, AL East)
PostseasonNone (3rd miss in 4 years)
ManagerJoe Girardi
Home/Road48-33 home (.593), 36-45 road (.444)
Sanchez20 HR in 53 games (MLB record pace)
All-StarsBetances, Miller, Beltran
Chapman Trade ReturnGleyber Torres (future All-Star SS)
Miller Trade ReturnClint Frazier, Justus Sheffield
A-Rod Final GameAugust 12, 2016 (696 career HR)

The Baby Bombers Are Born

The 2016 deadline deals changed the franchise's trajectory. Gleyber Torres would become an All-Star shortstop. Chapman was re-signed as a free agent in November for five years and $86 million -- meaning the Yankees got Torres for free and kept their closer too. (That's the kind of trade that makes rival GMs throw their phones against the wall.)

The fire sale also signaled a philosophical shift. For 27 years, the Yankees hadn't been sellers at the deadline. The Steinbrenner family's operating principle was always "spend to win now." But by 2016, Cashman had earned enough organizational trust to break with tradition and invest in the future. It was the most important strategic decision the franchise had made since signing Jeter out of high school in 1992.

The 2017 Yankees would win 91 games and reach the ALCS with a roster built around the prospects acquired in these trades. The Baby Bombers era -- Judge, Sanchez, Torres, and the young arms around them -- started in the summer of 2016, in the ashes of a fire sale that nobody wanted but everybody needed.

Chapman Traded to Cubs

Aroldis Chapman goes to Chicago for Gleyber Torres, Rashad Crawford, Billy McKinney, and Adam Warren. The franchise's most significant deadline deal in a generation.

Miller Traded to Indians

Andrew Miller, the best reliever in baseball, goes to Cleveland for Clint Frazier and Justus Sheffield. The fire sale continues.

Beltran Traded to Rangers

Carlos Beltran is dealt to Texas for pitching prospects Dillon Tate, Erik Swanson, and Nick Green.

Sanchez Arrives

Gary Sanchez is called up and hits 20 home runs in 53 games, providing the most exciting offensive debut in years.

A-Rod's Final Game

Alex Rodriguez plays his last game, finishing four home runs short of 700. The most polarizing Yankee of his era says goodbye.

Chapman Re-Signed

The Yankees re-sign Aroldis Chapman to a five-year, $86 million deal, keeping both the closer and Gleyber Torres.

McCann Traded

Brian McCann is dealt to the Astros for prospects. The old guard is officially gone.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the Yankees get for Aroldis Chapman in 2016?

The Yankees traded Chapman to the Chicago Cubs on July 25, 2016, receiving shortstop prospect Gleyber Torres, outfielders Rashad Crawford and Billy McKinney, and pitcher Adam Warren. Torres became a future All-Star. The Yankees then re-signed Chapman in November for five years and $86 million, effectively getting Torres for free.

How many home runs did Gary Sanchez hit as a rookie in 2016?

Sanchez hit 20 home runs in just 53 games after being called up in August 2016. That pace -- roughly one homer every 2.65 games -- was the fastest start for a rookie catcher in modern baseball history.

When was the last time the Yankees were sellers before 2016?

The 2016 deadline sales were the first time the Yankees had been sellers at the trade deadline since 1989 -- a 27-year gap. The franchise's philosophy of "buy now" had defined its approach for nearly three decades before Cashman broke with tradition.

When did Alex Rodriguez play his last game?

Rodriguez played his final game on August 12, 2016, finishing with 696 career home runs -- four short of 700. He'd announced his retirement five days earlier on August 7. The 14-year Yankee's career ended not with a farewell tour but with a quiet exit from a team that had already pivoted to youth.

Season Roster

Position Players (42)

PlayerPosG▼AVGHRRBIHRSBOBPSLGOPS
Didi GregoriusSS153.2762070155687.304.447.751
Carlos BeltránRF151.2952993163731.337.513.850
Starlin Castro2B151.2702170156634.300.433.733
Jacoby EllsburyCF148.2639561457120.330.374.704
Brett GardnerCF148.2617411438016.351.362.713
Chase Headley3B140.2531451118588.331.385.716
Brian McCannC130.2422058104561.335.413.748
Aaron HicksLF123.21783171323.281.336.617
Mark Teixeira1B116.204154479432.292.362.654
Billy ButlerDH97.28453571270.336.416.752
Dellin BetancesP73.00000000.000.000.000
Ronald Torreyes3B72.25811240202.305.374.679
Andrew MillerP70.00000000.000.000.000
Tyler ClippardP69.00000000.000.000.000
Alex RodriguezDH65.20093145193.247.351.598
Austin RomineC62.24242640171.269.382.651
Aroldis ChapmanP59.00000000.000.000.000
Rob Refsnyder1B58.25001238252.328.309.637
Adam WarrenP58.00000000.000.000.000
Gary SánchezC53.299204260341.376.6571.033
Kirby YatesP41.00000000.000.000.000
Chasen ShreveP37.00000000.000.000.000
Ben GamelRF33.18815990.278.292.570
Iván NovaP32.11500310.115.115.230
Michael PinedaP32.00000000.000.000.000
Tyler Austin1B31.2415122071.300.458.758
Masahiro TanakaP31.00000000.000.000.000
CC SabathiaP30.00000000.000.000.000
Dustin AckleyRF28.14804960.243.148.391
Nick GoodyP27.00000000.000.000.000
Aaron JudgeRF27.17941015100.263.345.608
Anthony SwarzakP26.00000000.000.000.000
Nathan EovaldiP24.00000000.167.000.167
Richard BleierP23.00000000.000.000.000
Chad GreenP12.00000000.000.000.000
Mason WilliamsRF12.29602840.321.333.654
Donovan Solano3B9.22712550.261.455.716
Ike Davis1B8.21401320.267.214.481
Phil CokeP6.00000000.000.000.000
Chris Parmelee1B6.50024440.5001.3751.875
Eric Young Jr.LF6.00000021.000.000.000
Conor MulleeP3.00000000.000.000.000

Pitching Staff (29)

PitcherG▼GSWLERAIPSOBBSVWHIP
Dellin Betances730363.0873.012628121.12
Andrew Miller7001011.4574.11239120.69
Tyler Clippard690463.5763.0722631.27
Tommy Layne630213.6344.2382111.30
Aroldis Chapman590411.5558.09018360.86
Adam Warren581744.6865.1522901.35
Kirby Yates410215.2341.1501901.45
Chasen Shreve370215.1833.0331311.27
Iván Nova32261284.17162.01272811.25
Michael Pineda32326124.82175.22075301.35
Masahiro Tanaka31311443.07199.21653601.08
CC Sabathia30309123.91179.21526501.32
Nick Goody270004.6629.0341201.45
Anthony Swarzak260125.5231.031701.13
Nathan Eovaldi2421984.76124.2974001.31
Richard Bleier230001.9623.013401.04
Luis Severino2211385.8371.0662501.45
Luis Cessa179444.3570.1461401.11
Blake Parker170104.6717.115911.50
Johnny Barbato130127.6213.015501.38
Chad Green128244.7345.2521511.40
Ben Heller100106.437.06402.14
Jonathan Holder80005.408.15401.44
James Pazos701013.503.13102.40
Phil Coke60003.6010.04701.70
Bryan Mitchell55123.2425.0111201.52
Conor Mullee30003.003.04401.33
Tyler Olson10006.752.20201.88
Branden Pinder100018.001.01104.00